Immigration in America – here is an immigration essay that discusses the misconception about immigrants and the reasons they enter into the U.S. without the proper documentation.
Free Immigration Essay Sample
Misconception on Immigrants and the reasons to Illegal Immigration
The issue of immigrants in the US is a huge problem that has continued to face the nation for many years. The issue has become a significant problem to American policymakers because some individuals who move into the US do so without following out the laid out policies and procedures becoming illegal immigrants. In this essay, there is a discussion on the topic of immigration with a particular focus on the misconception surrounding immigrants and the reasons they enter the US without proper documentation.
The debate surrounding the issue of immigration has two sides. On one hand, there exists a group of people that argue refugees and immigrants across different parts of the world should be allowed into the United States. On the contrary, there is a second group that maintains that immigrants and refugee should not be allowed into the American soil. Undoubtedly, there are different reasons offered by the two opposing sides to make firm their argument. In 2017, President Trump issued a temporary travel ban on immigrants from eight Muslim countries. During his campaigns, Trump vehemently vowed to enforce a travel ban on Muslims to the United States (Siddiqui, 2017). Also, he stood aggressively against accepting refugees from Syria arguing that some of the refugees moving from Syria could be Isis intending to run away from a war-torn nation. Therefore, it is essential to look at some of the misconceptions that people have concerning refugees or immigrants who move into the US annually.
There is a general misconception among some American nationals that immigrants are the primary cause of high crime rates in the US. The fact is, according to a 2015 report filed by the American immigration council, immigrants are less likely to be incarcerated compared to native-born nationals (Haines, 2015). Also, incarceration rates among young immigrant men are low especially for immigrants from Mexico, Guatemala, and Salvador who are notorious for illegal immigration. The council made an exciting finding that indeed high rates of immigration lead to low crime rates. Another misconception is that refugees from the Middle East are terrorists and a ticking time bomb who can jeopardize the peaceful nature of America. However, it is crucial to mention that, most immigrants are highly vetted before getting into the US by different government organizations including the FBI, Homeland security, and the Department of State where the process takes at least two years. According to Mascarenaz, (2017) out of more than 700,000 refugees who migrate into the US, only three individuals have been arrested so far due to connections with terrorism from the time of the September 11, 2001 attack. In the same vein, in an article by Newland, refugees are considered as a non-threat to the peace of the United States (Newland, 2015).
There exist a misconception that immigrants and refugees move into the US for welfare benefits. However, according to the laws and policies of the US government, undocumented immigrants are illegible for any Federal benefits programs. That means such immigrants are not legible to receive benefits until they have lived in the US for at least five years or more irrespective of how much they earn. However, it is not the same case when it comes to a group of refugees that are supported using Federal and State funds as soon as they get into the US. For definition sake, a refugee is said to be an individual who flees his or her country due to different circumstances such as war, prosecution or natural disaster. Most of the time, such refugees enter the US without proper resources and ability to survive. Therefore, they are taken by the US government as visitors who require humanitarian aid and thus receive benefits.
Undoubtedly, every child has a right to education as stipulated in the American Constitution. However, there is a misconception and argument that children of undocumented immigrants should not receive any form of free public education. However, as earlier mentioned, every child in the US between the ages of five and twenty one has a legal right to be in school no matter the status of their documentation. In fact, in 1982 the Supreme was clear through the case of Pyeler V. Doe where it ruled that states have no legal right to deny a student the right to free education because of their immigration status (Yeager, 2018). Therefore, educators are left with a crucial role in teaching learners on what information is right or wrong concerning immigrants.
It is clear that there are many undocumented immigrants in the US. Therefore, it is essential to answer the question or consider the fact why many individuals get into the US without proper documentation. In a news article by the American Voices, the answer to the question is from a logistical standpoint. That is, many immigrants get into the US without proper documentation because there exists no line for the many individuals across the world to get into and the primary argument that there is no clear way of correcting undocumented status (America’s Voice, 2017). The process that leads to legal permanency in the US is not an option for many people as there are only three options where an individual can immigrate, employer-based immigration, family-based immigration, and asylum. Therefore, just a few options are left for the many people who would love to get permanent residency in the US leading to illegal or undocumented immigration.
The issue of undocumented immigration is a massive problem in the US, and the problem will most likely continue. Although the debate on immigration has two sides, one side of the discussion lays down its facts based on misconceptions and ill-represented facts. There are enough evidence and statistical facts that show immigrants are not as bad as people consider them. Also, although every individual who moves into the US would love to do so through proper channels, the few options left for them are not enough.
Haines, D. W. (2015, November 25). Learning from Our Past: The Refugee Experience in the United States. Retrieved from https://americanimmigrationcouncil.org/research/refugee-experience-united-states
Mascareñaz, L. (2017, January 30). What Do I Say to Students About Immigration Orders? Retrieved from https://www.tolerance.org/magazine/what-do-i-say-to-students-about-immigration-orders
Newland, K. (2015, October). The U.S. Record Shows Refugees Are Not a Threat. Retrieved from https://www.migrationpolicy.org/news/us-record-shows-refugees-are-not-threat
Siddiqui, S. (2017, October 25). Trump ends refugee ban with order to review program for 11 countries. Retrieved from https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2017/oct/24/trump-refugee-ban-end-immigration-executive-order
Voice, A. (2017, July 25). Immigration 101: Why Can’t Immigrants Just “Get Legal”, “Get in Line” and Get Their Papers? Retrieved from https://americasvoice.org/blog/immigration-101-why-immigrants-cant-just-get-legal/
Yeager, T. (2018). Institutions, transition economies, and economic development. Routledge.
Immigration Essay Outline
- The issue of immigrants in the US is a huge problem that has continued to face the nation for many years.
- In this essay, there is a discussion on the topic of immigration with a special focus on the misconception surrounding immigrants and the reasons they enter into the US without proper documentation.
- The debate surrounding the issue of immigration has two sides, those who oppose and those who propose.
- The government has been one of the largest opponents in the immigration debate.
- The travel ban issued by Donald Trump in 2017 restricting the travel of Muslims to the United States.
- There is a general misconception among some American nationals that immigrants are the major cause of high crime rates in the US.
- Refugees from the Middle East are terrorists and a ticking time bomb who can jeopardize the peaceful nature of America.
- Immigrants and refugees move into the US for welfare benefits.
- Children of undocumented immigrants should not receive any form of free public education.
- Reasons for Illegal Immigration
- There exists no line for the many individuals across the world to get into.
- There is no clear way of correcting undocumented status.
- Restating the problem of immigration in the US.
- Summarizing the paper.